When Blake's girlfriend breaks up with him right before a speech at his best friend, Dave's wedding, Blake turns to the online dating scene after being pressured by Dave's new wife, Autumn. From there, Blake goes on a series of nightmare dates with young ladies he meets on the Internet and things get hilariously chaotic as he meets a lawyer-by-day-stripper-by-night, accidentally sets up a date with a mentally-handicapped woman, and many others in his search for the perfect mate, all while rooting on his Baltimore Ravens every Sunday at a local Delaware bar where he tells his friends of his woes. When Blake doesn't have much luck on the dating scene, he turns to his cousin, Kyle, for help. Kyle is a renowned ladies man, who has been known to hang the undergarments of women he fornicates with on his wall. With Kyle at the helm of Blake's dating life, things look like they may go in a downward spiral while Blake searches for his soulmate.